For over 25 years, the Sheriff’s Museum in Old Town, San Diego, welcomed families and law enforcement enthusiasts to explore its rich history. However, the museum has now closed its doors, and the property at 2384 San Diego Avenue is up for sale. This historic site, offered by Commercial Asset Advisors, is available for $3.4 million.
Chris Bonar, the listing agent, explained that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly impacted the museum’s operations, leading to the decision to sell. The building, spanning nearly 7,000 square feet on a 0.18-acre lot, has a unique history. Although it was believed to house the original San Diego Sheriff’s jail in the 1800s, Bonar found records indicating it was built in the 1970s.
The Honorary Deputy Sheriffs’ Association (HDSA), which owns the building, used it for various community purposes over the years. Heather Araiza, HDSA’s executive director, noted that while the building has served the community for decades, changing needs prompted the sale. The property’s sale marks the first time it has been on the market in 25 years.
The museum, once a charming spot for tourists and locals alike, was part of a historical journey through Old Town. Visitors often encountered the El Campo Santo Cemetery and the embedded grave markers nearby before reaching the museum, where a vintage patrol car greeted them in the courtyard.
Even though it has closed, the museum’s influence remains significant. The HDSA, a volunteer group supporting law enforcement, initially purchased the building for various uses. Araiza mentioned plans for a wellness unit for deputies, but these were ultimately shelved in favor of selling the property. Artifacts and vehicles on loan to the museum have since been returned to their owners.
Interest in the property has been growing, with potential buyers considering its future use. Bonar suggested that the building is likely to be converted for medical or general office purposes, given its features, such as an elevator.
This sale represents a significant moment in San Diego’s history, as the property transitions from a beloved museum to its next chapter. Whether it becomes a medical facility or an office space, the building at 2384 San Diego Avenue will continue to be a part of Old Town’s ever-evolving story.
